Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies Recipe

If you grew up loving the comforting taste of a Brown Sugar Pop Tart, get ready for a nostalgic treat with a twist! These Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies are loaded with gooey cinnamon-sugar filling, baked until perfectly soft, and topped with a buttery cinnamon glaze that melts into every bite. Each cookie is the best part of a classic pop tart captured in super-sized cookie form—easy to make, absolutely indulgent, and perfect for sharing (if you can bear to part with any!).

Ingredients You’ll Need

The ingredient list might look a touch long, but each element plays a starring role in crafting the pillowy texture, caramel-like sweetness, and signature flavor of Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies. Here’s what you’ll need and why each is non-negotiable:

• Unsalted Butter: Forms the backbone of softness in both cookie and filling; room temperature for easy creaming is key.
• Granulated Sugar: Lends classic sweetness and helps with the cookie’s crisp edges.
• Light Brown Sugar: Brings deep, molasses notes to both the cookie dough and the gooey center.
• Eggs: Bind everything and create richness, making every bite deliciously chewy.
• Vanilla Extract: Amplifies sweet, warm notes for that bake-shop aroma.
• Cake Flour: Lighter than all-purpose, this gives you that plush, melt-in-your-mouth crumb.
• Cornstarch: A little cornstarch is a secret for ultra-tender, bakery-style cookies.
• Baking Soda and Baking Powder: The power duo for lift and just the right spread.
• Kosher Salt: Balances out all that sweetness with a little edge.
• Cinnamon: Earthy-spicy warmth makes each layer of flavor pop, especially in the filling and glaze.
• Powdered Sugar: The base of the smooth, glossy glaze that crowns each cookie.
• Milk: Loosens the glaze just enough to cascade over warm cookies.

How to Make Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies

Step 1: Cream the Butter and Sugars

Start things off with a mixing bowl (stand or hand mixer works beautifully). Combine the butter, granulated sugar, and brown sugar. Whip them together for about 2 to 3 minutes on medium-high speed until the mixture is light and fluffy. This not only dissolves the sugar into the butter but captures air for that signature tender cookie crumb. Add in the eggs and vanilla extract, then beat for another 1 to 2 minutes, watching the mixture become almost mousse-like in texture.

Step 2: Bring Together the Dry Ingredients

In a separate bowl, whisk together cake flour, cornstarch, baking soda, baking powder, and kosher salt. This mixture keeps your cookies soft and helps them hold their shape. Slowly add these dry ingredients to the butter mixture, mixing just until the dough forms and no streaks remain. Don’t be afraid to stop and scrape down the bowl as needed!

Step 3: Chill the Dough

Cover your finished dough and pop it into the fridge for at least an hour. This step is crucial—it gives the flour time to hydrate, firming up the dough so your Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies hold that gooey filling without spreading too much in the oven. If you leave it longer than an hour, let the dough sit at room temp for about 30 minutes before working with it.

Step 4: Make the Brown Sugar Filling

While the dough chills, stir together the filling: softened butter, brown sugar, cinnamon, and a small scoop of cake flour to bind it. The result should be a thick, spreadable mix. Scoop out heaping teaspoonfuls (about 2 teaspoons each), roll them into balls, and set them aside—you want them ready for building your cookies.

Step 5: Shape and Fill the Cookies

Scoop out the chilled dough using a 1/4 cup measure (generous, yes, but trust me!). Break each scoop in half, press a well into one half, and nestle in a ball of that rich cinnamon filling. Top with the other half of dough and pinch all the edges closed around the filling. Roll gently to make seamless balls so none of that treasure leaks out during baking.

Step 6: Bake to Perfection

Arrange the cookie dough balls on parchment-lined baking sheets, giving them a little room to expand (about 2 inches apart). Bake in a preheated 350°F oven for 11 to 13 minutes, until the tops look just set and the edges take on a light golden glow. Allow your cookies to cool on the sheet for five minutes, then move them to a wire rack to cool completely—which lets the filling set up perfectly inside.

Step 7: Glaze and Finish

As the cookies cool, whisk up the simple glaze: powdered sugar, cinnamon, melted butter, and milk. Mix until silky smooth, then spoon it generously over each cookie while they’re still slightly warm, letting the glaze drip and set around the edges. Give it 15 minutes to set up and you’ll have a trayful of Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies that look just as heavenly as they taste!

How to Serve Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies

Garnishes

These cookies are absolutely perfect with a swoosh of the cinnamon glaze alone, but you can take them up a notch! A sprinkle of extra cinnamon, a pinch of flaky sea salt, or even a dusting of edible gold leaf for that bakery look will make your Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies really pop on the plate.

Side Dishes

Enjoy your cookies with a tall glass of icy-cold milk, a hot cup of coffee, or cozy chai tea. Their warmth pairs beautifully with fresh fruit—think apple slices or crisp pear wedges—to balance the sweetness and add a little freshness to your treat platter.

Creative Ways to Present

Pile your Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies high on a vintage cake stand for nostalgic flair, or lay them in a gift box lined with parchment for the most heartwarming homemade gift. Little hands (and grownup ones!) love when you stack these up bakery-style, or use them as a show-stopping centerpiece on a dessert board with caramel popcorn and chocolate-dipped pretzels for a DIY treat bar.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

These cookies store like a dream! Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3 days, or tuck them in the fridge for up to a week. The filling stays gooey and the glaze remains lusciously soft, making them just as irresistible for days—a rare feat in the world of filled cookies.

Freezing

If you want Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies at a moment’s notice, freeze the baked (but un-iced) cookies on a baking sheet until solid, then transfer to a freezer bag for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge, then glaze fresh before serving. You can even freeze the filled cookie dough balls before baking: just place the prepped dough on a sheet to freeze solid, then toss them in a freezer-safe bag. Bake straight from the freezer (adding 1–2 minutes to baking time) for a just-baked treat any day.

Reheating

To recapture that fresh-from-the-oven experience, warm cookies in a 300°F oven for about 5 minutes, or give them 10–15 seconds in the microwave. If glazed, warming gently will make the icing slightly melty and extra dreamy—just like the middle of a classic pop tart!

FAQs

Can I use all-purpose flour instead of cake flour?

Cake flour is what gives these cookies their signature tender bite, but you can use all-purpose in a pinch. Just know the cookies may turn out slightly denser. If possible, reduce the all-purpose flour volume by 2 tablespoons per cup to keep things light.

Can I make Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies gluten-free?

Absolutely! Simply swap in your favorite 1:1 gluten-free baking flour blend for both the cookie dough and the filling. The texture may vary slightly, but the brown sugar and cinnamon flavor still shines.

Is it possible to make these in advance for a party?

These cookies are the ultimate make-ahead treat. You can fully bake and glaze them up to two days ahead, or prep and freeze the filled dough balls for fresh, perfectly gooey cookies on party day.

What if I don’t have a stand mixer?

No worries! A sturdy hand mixer works just as well. If you don’t have either, you can even make the dough with a wooden spoon and some elbow grease—the key is creaming that butter and sugar until it’s noticeably fluffy.

How do I prevent my cookies from spreading too much?

This comes down to butter temperature and chilling. Make sure your butter is just room temperature (not warm) and don’t skip the chilling step. If you have the time, you can even chill the shaped, filled cookie balls before baking for ultra-thick Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies.

Final Thoughts

If you’ve ever wished you could turn your favorite childhood breakfast into the ultimate cookie, this is the magic recipe you’ve been waiting for. Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies are a true treat for cinnamon lovers and nostalgia chasers alike. Give them a try—you might just start a new sweet tradition!

Print